Why the Publicity Bubble in PR Begs Popping

September 17th, 2008 § 0

 There’s been talk lately about the PR pro’s evolution from publicist to social media strategist. While I wholeheartedly support the increased attention to social media, the underlying message is disconcerting. For too long, media relations and the hot pursuit of “ink” has been our reason for being. Let’s pop that bubble right now.

PR has never meant press relations, but to look at the industry’s widespread propagation of that mantra it would seem that is the case. How is it that we term ourselves publicists, when our true role encompasses so much more? Perhaps if we treated the industry as a more strategic practice instead of focusing on getting a stack of clips, we’d have more seasoned and capable professionals in the field instead of an army of cold callers smiling, dialing, and pissing off droves of journalists and bloggers in the process.

It’s interesting that despite the growth of social media and the decline of mainstream media, the importance of the latter has stayed virtually the same. There’s still a lot of resistance, most of all from PR professionals, to admit that traditional media relations is declining in importance and we live in a brave new world where social media is taking over.

A hit in the Wall Street Journal is a great coup and will no doubt cement the reputation of your brand with your consumers, your business partners, and your competition. But it’s becoming less and less valuable to the bottom line as social media grows exponentially in influence.

One example that continues to blow my mind is when a client of mine was included in a Thanksgiving-day GMA segment – a major accomplishment for our team. The client saw thousands of inbound leads occur as a result and was pleased as punch with the results.

Imagine his (and our!) surprise a few months later when we secured the client blog coverage on TMZ – which was still a relatively small celebrity-focused news site at the time – to phenomenal results that blew GMA’s out of the water. When a niche-focused Web site can bring in more bang than a nationally-syndicated morning show, you stop and pay attention.

The Internet tips the scales in favor of social media by making it far easier to track online coverage that leads to site traffic, leads from that traffic that convert into sales, and gauge customer opinions by participating in the online discussion.

Beyond online coverage’s potential for being far more successful than mainstream media coverage, the possibilities for community engagement is endless and gives companies a better chance than ever before of dialoguing with their most important publics: The end user. These direct-to-consumer conversations are arguably the most important for a company, and PR can strategize for and drive those conversations.

Social media provides PR professionals an opportunity to take back their rightful role as big thinkers, strategists and high-touch relationship builders, relegating media relations to a more modest (and arguably more deserved) position with the rest of a company’s key audiences.

It’s no wonder most clients still value the old school “ink” and pooh-pooh social media coverage as a lesser accomplishment when we so poorly represent ourselves as mere media lackeys. Yes, it’s time to expand beyond the publicist role, but in the process, we should realize that we never should have represented ourselves so narrowly in the first place.

[The above image, "POP!" by N1NJ4 on Flickr, used under Creative Commons]

[I originally contributed this post to my friend Chris Lynn's blog, socialTNT.]

Shout out to my PR brother, Chris Lynn of socialTNT

August 13th, 2008 § 0

My good friend, mentor, editor and former colleague Chris Lynn posted on his blog today about leaving SHIFT. Last Friday was a very sad day for all of us in the San Francisco office as Chris packed up his things and prepared for the next step in his career journey.

Chris was not just a social media guru, whip-smart talent, and all-around fab PR pro to me. He challenged me to become a better professional and to strive for greater heights in my own career. He was my partner in crime at industry tech parties, someone I grabbed lunch with, the guy who made all of us in the office laugh with his good-natured humor and sharp wit and was constantly the life of the party when us SHIFTers would get together for drinks after hours. I know he’ll continue to be an integral part of my life even as he moves past SHIFT and onto the next horizon.

I’ll miss you, Chris, but I’m so happy for you and I can’t wait to see you go on to more successes in your career!

A favorite pic I took of Chris with the lovely Kristen Nicole of Mashable at StumbleUpon’s 5 million users party at 111 Minna in SF

Our Modern Lives: Tune In or Turn Off?

April 16th, 2008 § 0

This is a post I contributed to my friend Chris Lynn’s blog, socialTNT.

With Blackberries and iPhones keeping us constantly connected to an online IV stream, it’s becoming increasingly more difficult to disconnect. As of late, discussion around the problems of our “always on” lifestyles seem to be popping up everywhere. Last month, the Churchill Club held a panel on the issue of information overload. And, even more alarming, The New York Times recently chronicled the health problems–and two deaths–resulting from the demands of round-the-clock blogging. While not as severe as those tragic cases, I recently came face-to-face with my own info-addiction.

Click here to read the rest of my post on socialTNT.

[The above photo, “Streeter Seidell, Comedian” by Zach Klein on flickr, is used under Creative Commons]

PR Students, Teachers, Pros Step Up to the PROpenMic

April 15th, 2008 § 0

I just joined PROpenMic yesterday, a community for PR students, educators, and pros to convene and share information, questions, and wisdom on the industry. It was created by famed PR educator and blogger Robert French of Auburn University, and from my experience so far is a great resource for PRs across the board to meet others and collectively share information. I wish I had this when I was in college getting my PR degree!

The community is a helpful training ground for students and young PR pros, and is also a great way for seasoned PR practitioners to mentor the newbies. I’m a huge fan of the site already from the little I’ve tinkered with it. I look forward to getting involved and meeting new people in the industry, as well as hopefully contributing some worthwhile info to the community.

Check it out for yourself and get signed up! And while you’re on there, go ahead and add me as a friend. ;)

Why (Good) PR Will Never Die

April 10th, 2008 § 0

I’ve been reading a book on media relations that’s been a great resource for me: Media Training 101 by Sally Stewart. It’s a good primer on smart PR tactics when working with press.

The interesting thing about the book is that it’s primarily geared toward executives and business people. Not PR pros.

Why is that funny? Having worked with quite a few execs throughout my career, I can’t imagine them having the time to read a book on media relations strategy.

Many of my clients can’t find time for a good night’s sleep, let alone the 4-6 hours it takes to read a 300-page book. You understand this when you get e-mail responses from your CTO after 10 p.m. at night and realize they’re still hard at work.

Which is what led them to hire a PR firm or consultant in the first place. The reality is it takes quite a bit of training to develop smart communication strategies for your brand.

That doesn’t even take into account the man hours needed to implement the plan once you put it together.

Reading through those pages is a reminder of how much training good PR pros need in order to prove their worth as true experts in communication. This now includes knowledge of traditional media outlets, key audiences, social media platforms, and any other new communication tools pop up along the way.

PR is a lot of hard work and the bar of excellence is high. If you’re a PR pro, you know how tough it is, and if you’re a journalist or blogger, you value the good PR people that are out there.

If it wasn’t challenging for companies to communicate effectively to their various audiences, the need for PR wouldn’t exist. And that’s why good PR, the kind that uses communication tools intelligently and gets results, will never die.

Me, myself and I have a pep talk about blogging

March 13th, 2008 § 0

My friend Larry Chiang from duck9 mentioned me today in a post he wrote for Found|READ, linking to this blog. I read it, realized that people might actually be visiting my blog as a result, and scurried to put together this post. :)

Clearly, flackette has become woefully out-of-date. While I’ve been posting semi-regularly at my friend Chris Lynn’s blog, socialTNT, I’m sad that flackette isn’t getting any attention.

Sometimes it gets so hard to blog regularly, especially if you’re blogging professionally. Many of us are still trying to focus on honing our 9to5 career skills so that we actually HAVE the insight to speak from a position of experience about our professions. One thing I definitely don’t want to be is a lotta talk without anything to back it up.

How does the young professional balance blogging with career growth and maintaining that critical work/life balance? It’s no easy feat, as evidenced by the many young PR bloggers who started out strong and then leveled off in activity when the cubicle came a-callin’.

So I’m giving myself a pep talk, because I do think blogging’s important and I need to get on the ball. Here goes:

Remember that you started blogging because it’s fun! For most of us, blogging is a labor of love. Don’t forget it. If you let blogging become a chore, you’re that less likely to expend your energy doing it.

Don’t overthink. I admit it, I’m a perfectionist. I’ve got so many half-baked posts in my pipeline but finalizing them? A whole ‘nother story. I’m working on it because I know it holds me back. Penelope has some great tips on this.

Yes, you might get burned, but it’s worth the risk. It’s scary to put your ideas out there, but the odds are you’ll find more allies than critics.

Get inspired. Read blogs by the people that you admire, and use them as a fount of inspiration. Some of my favorite blog “mentors”? Shel Holtz, Penelope Trunk, Jeremy Pepper, Chris Lynn, Kami Huyse, Todd Defren, and of course, you too Larry.

    Now wasn’t that cathartic? I think so. Now time to learn it, love it, live it.

    [The above photo, “pep talk” by .suzanne, is used under Creative Commons]

    Beyond the Beacon post: Why Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg should blog more often

    December 6th, 2007 § 0

    BUF207I’ve fallen out of love with Facebook as of late, for personal reasons that occurred previous to the Beacon fiasco and are not connected to its privacy issues. At one point I didn’t even log in for over a week! Perhaps that’s why I missed out on all the drama and infringements on personal privacy? That said, I haven’t been able to ignore the blogstorm that’s been brewing for the past two to three weeks due to consumer outrage at the ramifications of the new advertising platform.

    After numerous incendiary blog posts and media commentary on the issue, yesterday marked a turning point as we finally saw a personal response to users from the man himself on Facebook’s official blog: founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg. It was great to see Mark finally addressing the issues through a medium that really speaks to the Facebook community. And then I noticed his painfully obvious lack of involvement in Facebook’s blog…

    On the Facebook blog, Mark has only written 4 posts in the past year plus. Yup, that’s right. Just shy of one per quarter. And all but the first post (which describes the change in the social network’s name thefacebook.com to just Facebook, in addition to forward looking thoughts on the future of the site) are reactive responses to negative rumblings from the community.

    It makes me uneasy to see that nearly all of Mark’s blog posts have disagreeable associations attached to them. It would be great to see more positive posts that demonstrate his ability to communicate with users via the Facebook blog beyond using it as a personal apology page. Granted, there are a ton of other Facebook employees blogging regularly about exciting new developments in the platform, but Mark is the most publicly visible spokesperson for the company which makes his blogging presence on the site that much more important.

    We’ve got to give Mark at least a few Brownie points for attempting to be transparent about Facebook’s problems with the few posts he has written. However, it would be a wise PR move on his part to communicate more frequently about Facebook’s journey as a company. Like it or not, Mark is the most public "face" in Facebook, and given Facebook’s role at the center of the social media spectrum, his active participation in the conversation isn’t just advisable, it’s essential–and not just when a crisis brings the heat.

    John Biggs of CrunchGear Tells Us His PR Christmas Wish

    December 4th, 2007 § 0

     This morning, John Biggs of CrunchGear posted on what PR people can do this Christmas to make him happy. A lot of these tips are just plain common sense that can never be over-repeated, such as:

    • Don’t lie
    • Don’t waste time
    • Know who you’re pitching

    The other tips that John includes are just great fodder for how to approach CrunchGear intelligently. This is a must read for all PRs. Let’s give John what he’s wishing for, and hope that his perception of the profession can change from viewing us as largely underhanded Grinches to gracious Santas bearing gifts of interesting products and gadgets he can actually write about. :)  Hat tip to Peter Himler at The Flack.

    Important Words for the Young Workforce from Brazen Careerist's Penelope Trunk

    December 3rd, 2007 § 0

    Yesterday while on my nightly run, I tried giving up my usual jogging tunes and replacing them with the Forward podcast, managed by my longtime friend and fellow PR blogger Paull Young. I have to say, tunes were not missed and I thoroughly enjoyed the mental stimulation of the podcast coupled with the energy of the run.

    For this edition Paull interviewed Penelope Trunk, author of Brazen Careerist: The New Rules for Success and a career columnist at Boston Globe and Yahoo Finance. The interview was an incredibly inspirational listen, and provided a great deal of encouragement to us 20-somethings trying to make a living and change the world while we’re at it.

    I suggest you listen to the interview for yourself, but Penelope made two particularly important points that I want to highlight:

    1. Today’s workplace allows you to prove your worth through your performance and industry insight, not just how many years you’ve been in your business

    2. The above is a gift not afforded to our parents or any other past generation

    I thought this was important because too few of us realize the power we have in our hands to really showcase our talents in a new and exciting way. We should cherish this privelege. We no longer have to drudge through a career for X number of years trying to catch a break. Now more than ever, we have the ability to become thought leaders by contributing to the knowledge base for our respective professions. How can we do this? It’s as easy as expressing our opinions intelligently and respectfully, whether it be through blogging, internal discussions with our managers and team members, or conversations with others in our profession.

    I’m also very interested in updates on Penelope’s upcoming business venture with young career bloggers Ryan Paugh and Ryan Healy, BrazenCareerist.com, which will be a network of bloggers writing about the intersection of work and life. This will be a great resource for those just entering the workforce, and I can’t wait to check it out (the Web site says it is “coming soon”).

    Lessons Learned from Amazon PR

    November 16th, 2007 § 0

    Yesterday while following Snitter, I noticed some particularly interesting tweets from Marshall Kirkpatrick of Read/Write Web that had an edge of foreboding for Amazon’s PR team. When I read his post this morning on some Amazon news that was given out under embargo and then taken back at the last minute, I was flabbergasted at the route Amazon PR chose to take.

    Not only did Amazon go back on an originally agreed upon embargo for some news they had in the pipeline within minutes of the embargo time, but to add insult to injury, they also drafted a statement for Marshall to clarify the situation that was…wait for it…written in the FIRST person. Yes, that’s right, Amazon tried to put words into a blogger’s mouth. Dangerous to say the least. Marshall’s post completely detailed the exchange, even down to providing the exact text that Amazon PR hoped he would plagiarize as his own.

    We don’t really know what was going on behind-the-scenes here. Maybe Amazon PR really didn’t know the news was postponed/canceled until the 11th hour and as such weren’t able to notify journos in a timely manner. All too often these types of situations get thrown at the PR team and although it’s not their fault, they’re the ones left to pick up the pieces and salvage the damaged relationships as best they can. We, as PR people, have to remember to be flexible. When stuff like this happens, you have to take a deep breath and move forward. Be honest about the situation and realize that you can’t strong-arm people into handling things the way you want. And as we see in this example, if you try to do so, you’ll just end up making your team and the company behind you look bad. Really bad. Not to mention add to the already loud complaints about the PR industry as a whole.

    I think we need to get over the desire to always “control the message” and realize that setting up the relationship for success is far more important. In the age of Web 2.0, you can’t expect to be able to have a one-way dialogue anymore. Two-way communication is key. Setting up the relationship is key. Promoting open, honest dialogue whenever possible is essential. As Marshall pointedly notes, Amazon PR’s actions in this situation really prove that they are neither open nor social. The “gatekeeper” role of PR, while still important in certain situations, is no longer as important as our expertise in facilitating communication. There is a point at which attempting to “control” the situation is no longer practical or advisable and all we can do is help our clients participate strategically in the conversation, sit back, and let the rest unfold organically.

    Chris over at SocialTNT also wrote a great post on this issue that is a good read.